Welcome to Mystic Market
Since taking over in 2022, we’ve had the pleasure of making LBI our second home. As a family-owned market, we believe in treating every customer like part of the family.
We’re proud to serve some of New Jersey’s best—using high-quality ingredients, generous portions, and a commitment to consistency that keeps people coming back.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting the island, stop in and experience what makes Mystic Market a must-visit spot on LBI.
Thanks,
The Mystic Family
Family owned
Since our family took over in 2022, Mystic Market has become a proud part of the LBI community. We’ve built a reputation as a must-stop destination by creating a welcoming atmosphere where every customer is treated like family.
Community First
We’re proud to support local suppliers and give back to the LBI community through partnerships, events, and everyday connections that make this island special.
Quality Promise
From our award winning breakfast sandwiches, subs, and lobster rolls, everything we serve is made with high-quality ingredients and generous portions—so every visit is worth coming back for.
Career Opportunities
Contact Us
Hungry Yet?
See What All The Buzz Is About
From beach days to family nights, Mystic Market has become a go-to for stacked sandwiches, fresh seafood, and unforgettable lobster rolls. See why locals and visitors keep coming back.
Community Highlights
